Skill nostalgia?
Sep. 9th, 2026 09:34 pmWhen doing my hobby, I take comfort in that - aside from preserving fanfiction and/or interesting documentation - I am creating something tangible and useful with my own hands. A way of having my own physical work in an era of the digital. I also take heart in the community I have found and the knowledge that I am a continuation of a skill that is valued across the world, bridging peoples and faiths across the winds of time and distance.
And from what I've been hearing, I'm not the only one. A recent Guardian article reported how many people now value traditional 'hands-on' trades such as metalwork and boatbuilding since most office jobs are in danger of being replaced by LLM's. Weaving and crocheting took off during the pandemic, introducing many people to a tactile hobby that is still larger than it has been a decade ago. I myself went to an illustration fair earlier this year where original artists showcased their work to a packed audience.
With the ubiquity of computing, people are taking more attention to crafts, skills and trades that have physicality.
But late last week, I stumbled across an article that asks us to question this return to hands-on labor. Are we doing this out of nostalgia? For a past that is seen through rose-tinted glasses? Are we doing this for self-improvement, or for escapism? If physical skills are valued, are we aware that it can lead to some dark messaging about labor? Of what sort of person to idolise or demonize?
For me, at least, I do bookbinding because it served several things: to help me pass the time; to save and conserve stories from internet deletion; to document histories people prefer to forget; to show my love and appreciation for media that has often been seen as childish, trite, or disgusting. From joining the fanbinding community, I also see myself as continuing a tradition that, for some cultures, errs close to the divine.
I don't see myself as being on a poster with a chiseled jaw and emphasizing masculine labor, but I can also see why some people would like me and others like mine to be that. For our case, a lot of us don't fit that image and would laugh at such an attempt. So my response to that article is this: so long as we take hands-on trades and crafts with an open mind, so long as these repopularisation of labors come with acceptence of the queerness of ourselves, we will never become the people on those masculine posters. And may we be all the better for it.








